2015-07-17

fast likelihood evaluations for the CMB?

Mike O'Neil and I worked on the real-space covariance function for the cosmic microwave background radiation. He summed the Legendre polynomials to convert the C_ell spectrum into an angle-space kernel or covariance matrix. He plotted the real-space covariance and it is very pretty; it shows the baryon acoustic feature and oscillates at huge angle. He then looked at some symmetries of the matrix: It can be expressed as a sparse sum of outer products. Because of this, it is possible that he can develop a fast method for matrix factorization, linear-algebra solve operations, and (log) determinant evaluations.

2015-07-16

momentum-driven winds, enfastening stellar models

At Galaxy Coffee, Jonathan Stern (MPIA) showed an analysis of quasar momentum-driven winds in the context of AGN feedback for galaxy evolution. He finds that the quasar radiation is not sufficient to drive the wind. In the discussion of the point Joachim Bestenlehner (MPIA) pointed out that Wolf–Rayet stars can have momentum-driven winds that exceed the naive radiation pressure L/c by a factor of five-ish. It relates to the fact that there are multiple scatterings of the radiation. Andrea Macció's (MPIA but soon NYU-AD) showed some nice work on simulations of small galaxies that are infalling in to the halos of larger galaxies.

Mike O'Neil came down to HD for two days (from Frankfurt) and we spent part of the afternoon understanding how to run and interpret PICO, which computes CMB power spectra. We started towards converting its output (which is in "ell" space) into a real-space covariance function. When we left work, O'Neil was looking at recurrence relations for Legendre polynomials!

We took advantage of O'Neil's presence to have a discussion with various MPIAers about interpolating grids of models (so that you can have a model defined everywhere in parameter space, but only compute it in full at a sparse set of points). He had various extremely useful points of advice. However, his reaction to the problem of interpolating 1-D LTE spectral models was not “do this kind of interpolation” but rather “I bet we can make the models run much, much, much faster!” So we downloaded the original Kurucz model paper [warning: huge PDF file] and began exegesis.

2015-07-15

star ages, exoplanet spectroscopy

At Milky Way group meeting, various projects were discussed. Marie Martig (MPIA) and Maria Bergemann (MPIA) are both looking at how we might extract stellar ages from stellar spectra. Martig is looking at the dredge-up of elements from the core into the stellar exterior. Bergemann is looking at how extremely weak chromospheric emission might adjust (minutely) the shapes of the Balmer lines. Both of these projects are directly relevant to what Ness and I are doing with The Cannon.

After lunch, the PSF coffee had two impressive presentations. In the first, Nestor Espinoza (PUC Santiago/Chile) showed very impressive transmission spectroscopy of transiting planets. He has some spectral features that are hard to explain, but he notes that they might be caused by some systematic problems with the pipelines. They are taking reasonably high resolution (few thousand) spectra, but binning them down for analysis; it is interesting to think about what could be done with non-trivial binnings of the spectra, that are customized to particular questions.

In the second presentation, Florian Rodler (MPIA) took time-domain spectra in the red side of the K band to find the forest of molecular CO lines in the inner planet in the Upsilon Andromeda multi-planet system. This system is amazingly complicated, with two super-Jupiters with huge mutual inclination, large eccentricity, and a (circular) hot Jupiter. It sure doesn't look like it could be stable! The system properties are known from a combination of radial-velocity monitoring (of the main star), astrometric monitoring (of the center of light), and direct detection (of the molecular lines from the hot Jupiter).

2015-07-14

debugging outliers

I spent the day debugging with various students. Eddie Schlafly (MPIA) and I helped Nina Hernitschek (MPIA) debug her Gaussian-process (plotting) code, I helped Kopytova debug her spectral fitting code, and Rix and I helped Anna Ho debug her LAMOST models. On the latter, I have a hypothesis that perhaps bad data (strange, corrupted, or physically odd stars) are distorting the data-driven model of The Cannon. In particular, if there are outliers, we will get bad results for the intrinsic scatter parameters in the model. This all came up because the goodness-of-fit measurements are coming in “too good”.

2015-07-13

my first Monday at MPIA

[Very few posts for the last few days, because I was on a mini-vacation and getting ready for the annual move to Heidelberg.]

My research day started in the garden with Rix, looking at Anna Ho's paper using The Cannon to transfer APOGEE-like stellar parameter labels onto stars with LAMOST spectra. We worked through the figures and made comments.

At the weekly PanSTARRS meeting, Nina Hernitschek (MPIA) showed beautiful samples of QSO candidates and RR Lyrae candidates found with time-domain analysis. Her method involves Gaussian-process modeling multi-band time-domain data, and then a supervised classification. The results are very convincing: For example, on a map of the sky with the MW dwarf galaxies and star clusters circled, there are clear overdensities of RRL stars in many of the circles. Also, the RRL stars clearly trace the MW halo, bulge, and disk. She also has incredible 3π maps of QSOs, which are amazingly isotropic near the Galactic poles, but also have many QSOs in (or near) the disk plane and even behind the Galactic center. I bet she has the best low-latitude QSO sample ever.

At lunch-time I had a conversation with Laura Inno (MPIA), Rix, Eddie Schlafly (MPIA), and others about Cepheid stars in the Milky Way disk. There should be tens of thousands but hundreds are known. Rix gave some very good reasons for finding them all: Cepheids are very young stars but they are cool (5000 K) not hot, so you can measure their abundances. They are also luminous, so you can see them at large distance and through the dust. We discussed how to find them with PanSTARRS and WISE data, perhaps starting from what Hernitschek has already done.

2015-07-08

GALAH data!

Today I got an unexpected treat when Melissa Ness showed me some new GALAH data from the HERMES instrument. The project is intending to take R 28000 spectra of about a million stars, and determine up to 30 element abundances, or something insane like that. Ness and I are looking at whether The Cannon could be used for basic parameter estimation and to assist in the long-run goals of the project. The data look absolutely beautiful and the first attempts with the data make it look like The Cannon will Just Work (tm). We are a bit concerned about continuum normalization, but aren't we always?

2015-07-07

#eprv, day 2

I spent the day at Extreme Precision Radial Velocities at Yale. It is a great meeting, because it is very focused on the instrumentation and code that underly radial-velocity planet search and characterization. Today was a stats-heavy day, with me, Eric Ford (PSU), and Tom Loredo (Cornell) leading off with pedagogical talks. I gave an entirely new (for me) talk about noise modeling, and it was followed by absolutely excellent questions (every question pointed out a talk slide I should have made). Loredo made a nice point, which is that statistics is not a method or tool, it is a language or framework for communicating about quantitative questions. I couldn't agree more!

At lunch, Ana Bonaca organized a gathering of probabilistic reasoners to discuss asteroseismology with Sarbani Basu (Yale). This gave us an opportunity to feel out some of the issues if we try to build a probabilistic model (a forward model of the time-domain data) to replace the standard practice of Fourier transformations (or periodograms or the like). That was productive and useful.

In the afternoon, one talk that particularly stood out was by Xavier Dumusque (CfA) about The Keplerian Fitting Challenge. He made fake radial-velocity data, filled with difficult but realistic noise sources, and challenged groups to find and characterize the injected signals. He did a great job describing the successes and failures of the different groups, and even awarded nice bottles of wine to the two top-performing teams. This project, like the GREAT projects for weak lensing, are important community-building and critical-review projects for difficult data-analysis challenges.

2015-07-06

#eprv prep

I spent my research time today preparing my slides for the Extreme Precision Radial Velocity meeting at Yale. I am talking about noise models, arguing for creating and taking advantage of great flexibility, and then controlling complexity with priors or regularization or hierarchical inference. I also want to give some ideas about how, technically, we do what we do.

2015-07-04

the probabilistic properties of The Cannon

I wrote text in the “Methods and data” section of the mass-and-age paper I am writing with Ness. I emphasized particularly the point that The Cannon is a probabilistic model: It is a likelihood function, which is optimized at training time, and then again at test time. The only difference between training and test is which parameters are varied. In the former, it is the spectral expectation and variance parameters, at fixed label values. In the latter, it is the label values, at fixed spectral expectation and variance parameter values. The cool thing about this likelihood formulation is that it makes it trivial to account for heteroskedastic noise variances and missing data (in both the training data and the test data).

2015-07-02

writing about ages

I wrote a paragraph in the paper Ness and I are writing about inferring stellar ages from spetroscopy.

2015-07-01

chaos!

It is the summer, and it feels like I am getting lots done! That said, I only got in a small amount of serious research time today. I spent most of it commenting on a draft manuscript from Price-Whelan on chaos in the halo of the Milky Way. Yes, dynamical chaos. This is the coming to fruition of a pretty old idea at CampHogg: What is the difference between stellar streams on regular orbits and those on chaotic orbits? It turns out that the differences are bigger than we expected!

2015-06-30

star-formation history of the Milky Way

I read (or skimmed, really) some classic papers on the star-formation history of the Milky Way, in preparation for re-asking this question with APOGEE data this summer. Papers I skimmed included Prantzos & Silk, which infers the SFH from (mainly) abundance distributions and Gizis, Reid, and Hawley, which infers it from M-dwarf chromospheric activity. I also wrote myself a list of all the possible ways one might infer the SFH. I realized that not all of the ways I can think of have actually been executed. So now I have a whole set of projects to pitch!

2015-06-29

yet more K2 proposal

How can a 6-page proposal take more than six days to write? Also signed off on Dun Wang's paper on his pixel-level self-calibration of the Kepler Mission. Submit!

2015-06-26

more K2 proposal

In my research time today, I kept on the K2 proposal. I made the argument that we want K2 to point less well in Campaign 9 than it has in previous Campaigns, because we want the crowded field (which is in the Bulge of the Milky Way) to move significantly relative to the pixel grid. We need that redundancy (or heterogeneity?) for self-calibration. I hope that—if we get this proposal funded—we will also get influence over the spacecraft attitude management!

2015-06-25

K2 flat-field

I spent my research time today working on my proposal for K2 Campaign 9. The proposal is to self-calibrate to get the flat-field, which is critical for crowded-field photometry (even if done via image differencing).