Showing posts with label gastrophysics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gastrophysics. Show all posts

2025-07-04

how did the Solar System form?

I saw a very nice talk today by Philippine Griveaud (MPIA) about how the Solar System formed. The idea is that the giant planets formed in an accretion disk. Their formation opened gaps and caused migration (first Type I and then Type II, if you must know :). That migration pulled them into a resonant chain. That is, if the giant planets formed the way we think they formed, they must have been in a resonant chain. But they aren't in such a chain now; what gives?

The idea is that when the gas is expended (or blown out by winds), the remaining planetestimals (think: asteroids, comets, Kuiper Belt objects) interact with the planets such that they get moved from orbit to orbit and eventually ejected. These dynamical interactions break the resonant chain, migrate the giant planets to their current locations, and scatter rocks and ice balls into the interstellar regions.

It was a great talk, but also led to a lot of interesting questions, such as: How does this all fit in with the formation of the rocky planets? And how does this square with our observations (growing rapidly, apparently) of interstellar asteroids? Oh and: How does all this connect to observations of debris disks, which I now (officially) love.

2024-01-22

Betz limit for sailboats?

In the study of sustainable energy, there is a nice result on windmills, called the Betz limit: There is a finite limit to the fraction of the kinetic energy of the wind that a windmill can absorb or exploit. The reason is often stated as: If the windmill took all of the power in the wind, the wind would stop, and then there would be no flow of energy over the windmill. I'm not sure I exactly agree with that explanation, but let's leave that here.

On my travel home today I worked on the possibility that there is an equivalent to the Betz limit for sailboats. Is there an energetic way of looking at sailing that is useful?

One paradox is that a sailboat is sailing steadily when the net force on the boat is zero (just like when a windmill is turning at constant angular velocity). In the Betz limit, the windmill is thought of as having two different torques on it, one from the wind, and one from the turbine. Sailing has no turbine. So this problem has a conceptual component to it.

2024-01-03

wind power

I met up with Matt Kleban (NYU) to discuss our dormant project on the physics of sailing. Our conversation ranged around many different things related to sustainable power. In particular, we discussed whether it was possible to take a energy or power point of view on sailing, which has to do with the work that the sailboat is doing on the water and on the air. I feel like there will be some symmetries in play there. We also discussed power generation with wind farms, including the Betz limit (which is a limit on how much power you can get out of the wind). Is there an equivalent of the Betz limit for a sailboat? Finally, Kleban made a remark that is simultaneously obvious and deep: If you have a propeller turning in a fluid (like air), it might be a turbine (generating power from the wind) or a fan (using power to make wind). The question of turbine or fan has a frame-independent (relativistically scalar) answer.

2023-07-24

convection, granulation, stellar spectra

I had a great and long conversation today with Maria Bergemann (MPIA) about building a model of a full stellar spectrum out of the models they build of small patches of stellar surface, with full 3D convection and full radiative transfer. Their models are sophisticated, and give a full spectrum in every direction from the surface patch. Thus we can integrate a set of patches into a surrogate combined spectrum for one rotating star covered in convecting patches. We discussed how we might do that, technically, and what projects we might then do with the output. What I want to do (yes, you guessed it) is build data-driven models of stellar granulation to improve radial-velocity surveys.

2023-04-18

a well-posed problem in gastrophysics

Magda Siwek (Harvard) gave an execellent NYU Astrophysics Seminar today, about evolution of binary systems when the binary is accreting from a circumbinary disk. She sets a few (just a few) disk parameters, and then sets the mass ratio and eccentricity of the binary, and seeks steady-state (low disk-mass or low accretion-rate) solutions. By ignoring electromagnetic fields and various bits of microphysics, she can create a setup that is completely scale-free, so it applies (approximately) from all scales from exoplanets to super-massive black holes. That's brilliant. She finds that the eccentricities are in general driven to non-zero steady-state values, which depend (strongly) on mass ratio and (maybe weakly) on disk parameters. That's a nice problem, and observationally relevant to projects we are doing right now.

2023-02-13

reproducibility; reionization

Today featured a blackboard talk by Soltan Hassan (NYU), about a semi-analytic model to explain the various bits of data we have about the reionization of the universe at redshifts around 7. The model is baroque, but there are no options when it comes to problems that are deep in gastrophysics.

After lunch I spent an hour on a panel organized by NYU Libraries about reproducibility in the natural sciences. That was fun; so many ideas! One interesting idea is that it is transparency, more than reproducibility, that is important. Another was a technical suggestion: If you want your students to be good at making reproducible code, they shouldn't bring you plots of their results, they should bring you code that you can run to make those plots! Haha, genius.

2023-02-03

thermodynamics of cosmic gas

The day ended today at Flatiron with a great Colloquium by Eichiro Komatsu (MPA) about the temperature of cosmic gas. Gravitational collapse heats the gas, and that takes it up to something like 2 million degrees. This was computed ages ago by Peebles and others, but is now measured. There was a lot of discussion during and after about other heating mechanisms, and what things constitute gravitational heating. I'm interested in whether this result meaningfully constrains scattering interactions between the dark matter and baryons; if they scatter, and the dm is heavier, the baryons will (eventually) get exceedingly hot.

2022-12-01

geometric convolutional networks

Today I had a great meeting with Wilson Gregory (JHU), Drummond Fielding (Flatiron), and Soledad Villar (JHU) about a project to learn partial differential equations from simulation data. This is a toy problem from our perspective, but it is a baby step towards big, real computational problems in physics. Fielding produces training data, Gregory produces geometric convolution networks, Villar proves things, and I cheer from the sidelines.

Our approach is to replace convolutional neural networks with geometric operators that are generalizations of convolutions that know more about geometric forms like vectors, tensors, pseudovectors, and so on. By building methods that use geometric objects responsibly, we automatically enforce coordinate freedom and other deep symmetries.

2022-11-07

what is the scope of our image models?

There is a bit of a disagreement between Soledad Villar (JHU) and me on the scope of the methods that we are building to operate on images of scalars, vectors, and tensors. Soledad's view is that they apply to physics problems, like fluids. Mine is that they apply to absolutely every image of every kind ever taken, like vacation snapshots. Today we had a meeting with Drummond Fielding (Flatiron) and Wilson Gregory (JHU) about making some training data from a small 2D fluids simulation. (That is, we were adopting, for today, Villar's position on our scope.) Apparently 2D fluids is a standard problem in machine learning these days? I can't imagine why. But anyway, on the call, Fielding promised to make us some toy data. And, tonight, he did. Awesome!

2022-09-14

stellar noise as a physical process

Today I was privileged to be part of a great and productive meeting between Jesse Cisewski (Wisconsin), Megan Bedell (Flatiron), and Lily Zhao (Flatiron) about noise sources in extreme-precision radial-velocity measurements. The conversation was inspired by the realization (obvious, really) that any physical effect on the surface of stars (spots, plages, convection pattern, p-modes, flares) that affect the radial-velocity measurement must (unless the Universe is truly adversarial) leave other imprints on the spectrum at the same signal-to-noise or even higher signal-to-noise. This means that any claim that RV measurements are affected by spots (say) should be backed up by an observation in the spectrum that is orthogonal to the RV signal that supports the claim. We discussed relevant research and decided to jointly read this paper before our next meeting!

2022-05-02

accretion and mathematical physics

In the CCPP brown-bag today, Andrei Gruzinov (NYU) went through the full mathematical-physics argument of Bondi (from the 1950s) that leads to the Bondi formula for accretion from a stationary, thermal gas onto a point mass. He also talked about a generalization of the Bondi argument that he developed this year (permitting the gas to be moving relative to the point mass) and also a bevy of reasons, both theoretical and observational, that the Bondi solution never actually applies ever in practice! Haha, but beautiful stuff.

2022-04-11

sailing

I gave a seminar at lunch today (black-board talk) about how sailboats work. I got lots of great comments and questions, especially about sailing down wind faster than the wind. I vowed to add a paragraph to my paper on sailing (with Matt Kleban) about how to sail this way. I think it is extremely hard to do, technically. So much so that some of the books on sailing say that it is impossible! It isn't, in principle.

2022-02-18

Friday: Hamlet and Horatio reboot

Lily Zhao (Flatiron), Megan Bedell (Flatiron), and I spoke about our linear regression methods for EPRV today. Our methods are called Hamlet and Horatio for reasons we have trouble articulating. But the idea is that if the confusing spectral variability in EPRV comes from surface features rotating in and out of view on the stellar surface, that should impart structure to the data that we can grab and exploit. We stepped back and asked what are the real, underlying assumptions of these methods. We didn't come to extremely clear positions, I am afraid. The future of this field, IMHO, is Doppler imaging spectroscopy of the entire rotating, evolving stellar surface!

2022-01-18

why does anyone need a bolometric correction?

As I mentioned yesterday, and against my better judgement, I am writing a long pedagogical document on magnitudes and how they work. I got to the bolometric-correction part and I realized that I didn't understand exactly why they are defined and how they are used. So I had a long think. The answer is: Theoretical models of stars are better at predicting the total bolometric luminosity output (energy per time) coming from a star than they are at predicting the detailed spectrum. Thus it makes sense to separate the belief about the total luminosity from the belief about the luminosity in any one band.

2022-01-03

a phase diagram for sailboats

Matt Kleban (NYU) and I are finishing up a paper on the theoretical basis for sailing (yes sailing). One of our conclusions is that (large) sailboats are described by three dimensionless ratios: The sail-to-keel ratio, the ratio of the sail working force to the air drag force, and the ratio of the keel working force to the water drag force. We imagined today a phase diagram that shows the space of dimensionless ratios that permit, for example, upwind sailing. And sailing downwind faster than the wind. And sailing cross-wind faster than the wind. And so on.

2021-12-31

other kinds of sailing

In finishing up the first draft (yay!) of my paper on sailing, I thought about other kinds of sailing (for the discussion). One is solar sails: In principle if a spacecraft has a sufficiently large solar sail, of which it can change the size and shape, the spacecraft can navigate in arbitrary directions and perform arbitrary three-axis attitude adjustments, by working on a combination of radiation pressure and gravity. It's really very flexible. It makes me want to design a spacecraft!

I also thought about ice boats. An ice boat is like a sailboat with an extremely large keel and almost no water drag. That is, it sails like a sailboat in the limit that the keel gets large but the water drag gets small. This should make ice boats extremely fast at upwind sailing. Maybe I'll try to find an opportunity to sail on ice this winter?

2021-12-23

sailing upwind; lift ratios; sail-to-keel ratio

In writing up a description of some of my physics-of-sailing results, I realized some things about sailboat design. For deep reasons you want the ratio of the area of the sail to the area of the keel to be roughly the ratio of the density of water to the density of air, or 700. That flows from the point that the sail and the keel have symmetric roles in sailing. But if you set this ratio to 700, you can only sail upwind if the sail lift ratio (the ratio of useful sail force to drag force) is very high. Since it is hard to make this lift ratio high on a commercial boat, the alternative is to make the sail smaller (relative to the keel). Looking at the data I can find on real sailboats, most have okay lift ratios but small sail-to-keel ratios (smaller than 700 anyway), so that they can sail quickly upwind. The cost of these design choices is that you can't go downwind faster than the wind. If you want to be able to sail both downwind faster than the wind—and also upwind—you have to have amazing sail and keel lift ratios.

2021-07-21

Gaia BP-RP spectral fitting

Hans-Walter Rix and I discussed with Rene Andrae (MPIA) and Morgan Fouesneau (MPIA) how they are fitting the (not yet public) BP-RP spectra from the ESA Gaia mission. The rules are that they can only use certain kinds of models and they can only use Gaia data, nothing external to Gaia. It's a real challenge! We discussed methods and ideas for verifying and testing results.

2021-07-05

physics-of-sailing literature

I sucked it up and read a bunch of the physics-of-sailing literature today (and on the weekend). Some of the books very correctly attribute the forces on sails and wings to momentum transport. Some of the books very incorrectly attribute them to differences of pressure calculable from Bernoulli effect alone. But in reading it all, I did come to the conclusion that no-one is working in precisely the space we want to work, so I do think there is a (correctly scoped) paper to write. Of course even if there weren't, I couldn't stop myself!

2021-06-30

extracting spectra using models or filters

I had an interesting conversation with Matt Nixon (Cambridge) today, about new ways one might extract spectra of stars if the true goal is exoplanet atmosphere transmission spectra. Right now most methods bin down the data until there is enough signal-to-noise in every bin/super-pixel to extract a difference spectrum in every pixel. But there are other ways to bin down, which could be guided by the theoretical spectral models. In the most extreme case, you would do the atmospheric retrieval (as they call it in the business) in the un-extracted 2D image data from the spectrograph! We discussed what pieces of technology would be needed to make this happen. I love this idea, because it is at the intersection of sophisticated hardware (these spectrographs are amazing) and sophisticated theory (the exoplanet atmospheres codes are non-trivial).