Today I presented out chemical-tagging results at Blanton–Hogg group meeting. We show that (now that we can see them with The Cannon) overdensities in chemical space appear also to be overdensities (or at least oddities) in phase space. I followed the meeting by making final edits to the paper, submitting it to the Astrophysical Journal and the APOGEE Collaboration, and putting it on the arXiv. I also sent it to friends and colleagues. This led to an email battle with Charlie Conroy (CfA), who believes our results are somewhere between trivial and wrong!
"This led to an email battle with Charlie Conroy (CfA), who believes our results are somewhere between trivial and wrong!"
ReplyDeleteDetails please